Buying a used car from a private seller can seem like a good deal, but it also comes with risks. In particular, many people wonder if the seller could be held legally responsible if the car is later involved in an accident due to undisclosed problems. Recent data shows that around one million used cars are sold privately each month in the U.S. Additionally, around 12% of car accidents annually involve mechanical failure issues. So, what obligations do private sellers really have? Could they end up in legal trouble down the road?
What Sellers Must Legally Disclose
The used car market operates on the legal principle of caveat emptor, meaning "let the buyer beware." This places the burden on the buyer to carefully inspect the vehicle prior to purchase. However, sellers do have certain legal obligations for disclosure under both state and federal lemon laws.
Federal law requires sellers to disclose branded titles, meaning the car has sustained damage so severe that the vehicle's history followed the car through to resale. Sellers must declare these past issues in writing so the buyer has a chance to reconsider the risks.
Additionally, state lemon laws can create responsibilities for private sellers to disclose known defects or previous accidents on a separate form, particularly those impacting safety or vehicle operation. Failure to disclose not only violates these laws but can open the seller up to fraud accusations later.
Liability After an Accident
For the most part, once the title transfers at the time of sale, legal liability linked to the vehicle also transfers over to the buyer. This means the new owner assumes responsibility for registration, taxes, repairs, and potential injury or damage stemming from future accidents.
However, exceptions exist in certain situations:
• If the seller knew about a defect but lied to the buyer when asked directly, liability protects the innocent purchaser. This constitutes fraud.
• When installment payments are still owed to the seller, some state laws prevent legal ties from fully severing until it is paid in full.
• If state forms failed to report required disclosures on past vehicle history or maintenance issues, the buyer could make a case for negligence responsibility.
While rare, buyers physically injured by undisclosed defects or faults have successfully sued private sellers for liability damages if they can prove intentional deceit or negligence.
Protecting Your Interests After an Accident
No used car buyer hopes to end up in an accident, but it's important to know your rights and options for recourse if it does happen. Here are some tips:
• Review the sales contract carefully and ensure the seller completed any state-required disclosure forms accurately before accepting delivery.
• Although they are not legally obligated, ask if the seller would agree in writing to disclose information on major repairs, collisions, or persistent problems. It can't hurt to ask.
• Independently research the vehicle history for title brands, accidents, or major issues. Paid services like Carfax provide this information based on registration records and insurance claims.
• Hire a trusted mechanic to inspect the car thoroughly prior to purchase, even if it means an extra fee. They may catch issues you would otherwise miss.
For example, if you find yourself injured in a car crash in New York City resulting from an undisclosed vehicle defect later, get help from an experienced team of NYC car accident attorneys as soon as possible. A lawyer who works in the same state as the auto accident can help determine if the seller violated any obligations and evaluate if compensation exists under fraud, negligence, or consumer protection laws. They may also negotiate with uncooperative sellers or their insurance company to reach a settlement on your behalf.
Purchasing from a private party comes with risks of limited legal recourse down the road. However, following these tips can help ensure you make an informed, safe purchase. Conduct due diligence upfront, and don't hesitate to contact a professional if issues emerge after an accident. Protecting yourself starts long before you take the keys and sign over that cash payment.
See Now: OnePlus 6: How Different Will It Be From OnePlus 5?
